In January, Democratic legislators will take majority control of the Pennsylvania state legislature, and Governor Josh Shapiro says he wants a $15 minimum wage to be the “very first” bill he signs. While the Governor may have the votes to achieve it, that doesn’t mean it’s a good idea.
A recent survey of US economists finds that 73 percent believe a $15 minimum wage will reduce jobs, while 74 percent say it will do a poor job helping those in poverty. The evidence also shows that a higher minimum wage can worsen the affordability crisis.
But if the state is set on creating a higher minimum wage, other states’ experiences show there are less-harmful pathways to get there. Jobs will still be lost, but not as many as would be otherwise. These ideas include a slower phase-in of $15, and full preservation of the state’s tipped minimum wage – a policy that is strongly supported by the tipped workers directly affected by the law.
An Immediate $15 Wage and Tip Credit Elimination Causes Greatest Damage
Pennsylvania currently follows the federal minimum wage of $7.25 an hour. The state also has a base wage of $2.83 for tipped workers, who are required to earn at least the state minimum between their base pay and tips. Earnings data shows this system is far more profitable for tipped workers: The average Pennsylvania server or bartender makes $27 an hour with their tips included.
To estimate the jobs impact of a $15 minimum wage in Pennsylvania, EPI followed methodology developed by the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office. Were Pennsylvania to raise its minimum wage from $7.25 to $15 immediately–with no phase in, and elimination of the tipped minimum wage–it would cost 78,345 jobs.
The restaurant industry would be hit particularly hard, with more than half (53%) of projected job losses occurring in restaurants and other food service establishments. Restaurants operate on notoriously thin profit margins, making them especially vulnerable to significant increases in labor costs. Faced with higher wages, restaurant operators could be forced to cut staff, reduce employee hours, or raise menu prices to offset the added costs.
The consequences could be especially severe for Pennsylvania’s youngest workers. Teenagers ages 16 to 19 would account for approximately 52% of projected job losses under a $15 minimum wage. With limited work experience and fewer skills, these workers could face greater difficulty finding entry-level jobs as employers become more reluctant to hire inexperienced workers at higher wage rates. This finding falls in line with decades of research that finds minimum wage hikes – particularly those aimed at the restaurant industry – cost workers their jobs and earnings.
Limiting the Damage: Preserving the Tipped Wage and a Wage Phase-In
Raising the minimum wage in Pennsylvania will destroy tens of thousands of jobs – the research is clear on this point. However, legislators can limit the damage by adopting two popular modifications.
The first: Preserving the tipped minimum wage. Of the nearly 80,000 jobs that would be destroyed by an immediate $15 minimum wage, more than 23,000 of those job losses are a consequence of tipped wage elimination. Projected job losses from a $15 minimum wage fall to 55,174 jobs when the tipped wage is fully-preserved at its existing level.
Tipped workers are still guaranteed the same minimum wage as all other workers, but with the flexibility to earn much more than that through tips. This doesn’t just make economic sense: It’s supported by the tipped workers themselves, and matches the approach that neighboring and nearby states have taken to great success. (More on that below.)
The second step legislators can take: Phasing in any increase to the minimum wage to give employers more time to adjust. This is what Maryland did when it adopted a $15 minimum wage, initially providing up to eight years for some smaller employers to adjust to the higher cost. (This timetable was later shortened to five years.)
The reduction in damage from a five-year phase-in of $15, with full preservation of the tipped wage, is remarkable: Rather than job losses nearing 80,000, the Commonwealth loses 33,460 jobs spread over a five year period.
Previous Tipped Wage Hike Attempts Slashed Worker Jobs, Earnings
On the tipped wage, legislators should learn from their neighbors’ good ideas–but also from their mistakes. In nearby Washington, D.C., the city attempted to eliminate the local tipped wage system. As it began raising the tipped wage over several years, tipped restaurant workers reported negative consequences.
EPI analysis of federal quarterly jobs data found the city had lost 5% of its restaurant industry jobs after the tipped wage hikes began in May 2023. Census Bureau data on workers’ earnings found servers and bartenders saw their overall earnings – including tip income – decline by up to $1,800 annually.
The fallout was so bad, data and local workers’ testimony pushed the D.C. City Council to pause future increases to the tipped restaurant worker wage, and preserve a tip credit going forward.
PA Should Follow Neighboring States That Have Preserved the Tipped Wage System
Surrounding Democratic-led states, such as Maryland and Virginia, have all raised their minimum wage rates over the last several years. But due to vocal concerns raised by local restaurant workers, each state has fully-preserved the base tipped wage system that allows these workers to make more than the minimum wage through tips. These states have also wisely phased-in higher wage levels that help reduce (if not fully eliminate) any job losses.
Pennsylvania would be wise to pursue different courses of action to address affordability. But if its leaders are dead-set on raising the minimum wage, the least they should do is fully preserve the tipped wage and phase in any new mandate.